What guidelines should nurses follow when considering whether or not a client requires restraints?

Restraints in a medical setting are devices that limit a patient's movement. Restraints can help keep a person from getting hurt or doing harm to others, including their caregivers. They are used as a last resort.

There are many types of restraints. They can include:

  • Belts, vests, jackets, and mitts for the patient's hands
  • Devices that prevent people from being able to move their elbows, knees, wrists, and ankles

Other ways to restrain a patient include:

  • A caregiver holding a patient in a way that restricts the person's movement
  • Patients being given medicines against their will to restrict their movement
  • Placing a patient in a room alone, from which the person is not free to leave

Restraints may be used to keep a person in proper position and prevent movement or falling during surgery or while on a stretcher.

Restraints can also be used to control or prevent harmful behavior.

Sometimes hospital patients who are confused need restraints so that they do not:

  • Scratch their skin
  • Remove catheters and tubes that give them medicine and fluids
  • Get out of bed, fall, and hurt themselves
  • Harm other people

Restraints should not cause harm or be used as punishment. Health care providers should first try other methods to control a patient and ensure safety. Restraints should be used only as a last resort.

Caregivers in a hospital can use restraints in emergencies or when they are needed for medical care. When restraints are used, they must:

  • Limit only the movements that may cause harm to the patient or caregiver
  • Be removed as soon as the patient and the caregiver are safe

A nurse who has special training in using restraints can begin to use them. A doctor or another provider must also be told restraints are being used. The doctor or other provider must then sign a form to allow the continued use of restraints.

Patients who are restrained need special care to make sure they:

  • Can have a bowel movement or urinate when they need to, using either a bedpan or toilet
  • Are kept clean
  • Get the food and fluids they need
  • Are as comfortable as possible
  • Do not injure themselves

Patients who are restrained also need to have their blood flow checked to make sure the restraints are not cutting off their blood flow. They also need to be watched carefully so that the restraints can be removed as soon as the situation is safe.

If you are not happy with how a loved one is being restrained, talk with someone on the medical team.

Restraint use is regulated by national and state agencies. If you want to find out more about restraints, contact The Joint Commission at www.jointcommission.org. This agency oversees how hospitals are run in the United States.

Heiner JD, Moore GP. The combative and difficult patient. In: Walls RM, Hockberger RS, Gausche-Hill M, eds. Rosen's Emergency Medicine: Concepts and Clinical Practice. 9th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier; 2018:chap 189.

Kowalski JM. Physical and chemical restraint. In: Roberts JR, Custalow CB, Thomsen TW, eds. Roberts and Hedges' Clinical Procedures in Emergency Medicine and Acute Care. 7th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier; 2019:chap 69.

Smith SF, Duell DJ, Martin BC, Gonzalez L, Aebersold M. Body Safe client environment and restraints. In: Smith SF, Duell DJ, Martin BC, Gonzalez L, Aebersold M, eds. Clinical Nursing Skills: Basic to Advanced Skills. 9th ed. New York, NY: Pearson; 2017:chap 7.

The Joint Commission website. The comprehensive accreditation manual for hospitals. www.jointcommission.org/accreditation/hospitals.aspx. Accessed October 24, 2021.

Updated by: David C. Dugdale, III, MD, Professor of Medicine, Division of General Medicine, Department of Medicine, University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, WA. Also reviewed by David Zieve, MD, MHA, Medical Director, Brenda Conaway, Editorial Director, and the A.D.A.M. Editorial team.

The CCTC Standard of Care for restraint use has been developed to comply with the LHSC Standard of Nursing Care for Restraint Use.  

Definition:

Restraints are any mechanical, chemical or environmental means which are intended to prevent injury or bring under control behaviours or physical movements which could cause bodily harm to patients or others.

Ensure that patient and health care provider safety standards are met during this procedure including:

  • Risk assessment and appropriate PPE
  • 4 Moments of Hand Hygiene
  • Procedural Safety Pause is performed
  • Two patient identification
  • Safe patient handling practices
  • Biomedical waste disposal policies
 

Practice Standard

1.

LHSC and CCTC supports a least restraint policy.

  • Effective restraint reduction requires innovative substitutes for the use of restraints.
  • Research has shown that 81% of patients who remove their endotracheal tube were restrained at the time.
  • Evidence also shows that the use of restraints contributes to depression, anger, nosocomial infection, and pressure ulcers.
2.

An assessment for alternative measures is done prior to the use of restraints.

  • Restraints are used only after other measures have been considered and are either unsuccessful or inappropriate.

See Delirium Protocol for strategies to prevent Delirium and engage family members in the prevention and treatment.

Click to obtain Decision Tree for the use of restraints in CCTC.

Document the alternate methods used and patient’s response.

  • Many reasons for restless and agitation can exist including:
    • Pain (e.g., from incisions, invasive lines, monitoring devices or prolonged bedrest)
    • Anxiety
    • Malfunction of catheters
    • Sleep deprivation
    • Drug reactions, interactions or withdrawal
    • Electrolyte imbalances
  • Restraints may contribute to further agitation and delirium.
3.

Ensure that restraints are applied safely and are approved for use at LHSC.

  • Restraints are indicated in isolated circumstances where there are risks of injury to the patient or others.
  • Restraint measures should allow as much autonomy as possible while promoting patient and staff safety.
4. The Patient/Family/Substitute Decision-Maker must consent to the use of restraints.
  • Prior to the use of restraints or as soon as possible once restraints have been initiated, the Family or Substitute Decision-Maker must be notified and their verbal consent documented in the AI flowsheet.
  • Discussion with the family should include:
    • the reason for the restraints
    • the alternatives that have been attempted or considered
    • the type of restraints to be used
    • the associated risks
    • the time frame for which restraints may be necessary
    • the risks associated with not restraining the patient
5.

If the family refuses the use of restraints despite being made aware of the potential risks to the patient or others, a “Consent for the Refusal of Physical Restraints” must be signed by the Family or Substitute Decision-Makers.

6.

Document the following in the AI record:

  • the behaviour that necessitated the use of the restraint
  • the date and time of initial application
  • the type of restraint used
  • the discussion with the Family/Substitute Decision-Maker
  • the verbal consent or refusal
  • observations regarding the effect of the restraint on the patient's behaviour

The Consent for Refusal for Restraint must be completed and left on the chart.

Careful documentation is important to demonstrate that the patient’s dignity, rights and independence were considered while attempting to maintain a safe environment for patients, visitors and staff.

7.

The patient must be reassessed and observed routinely while restraints are in place.

Injury risks from the use of restraints have been well documented.

8.

During initiation of restraints:

The following assessments must be made q 15-30 minutes X 1 hour , then every 15 – 60 minutes:

  • colour, circulation, sensation and motion of all restrained limbs
  • skin condition

Document findings on the A/I flowsheet.

Reported complications related to restraint use have been reported and include:

  • emotional difficulties
  • increased agitation
  • confusion
  • delirium
  • skin breakdown
  • circulatory dysfunction
  • respiratory compromise
  • brachial plexus injury
9.

During ongoing use of restraints:

  • Remove and reapply restraints q2h.
  • Reposition the patient q2h.
  • Monitor body alignment. Pay particular attention to ensure the shoulder is in proper alignment and not being strained.
  • Perform range of motion exercises q12h and prn.

The following assessments must be made q2h AND documented on the AI flowsheet:

  • colour, circulation, sensation and motion of all restrained limbs
  • skin integrity

Brachial plexus injuries can occur from stretching of the shoulder. This can lead to injuries ranging from arm and hand numbness to paralysis.

10.

Reassess the use of restraints q24h and document daily on the AI 24-hour assessment record.

Patient's restraint requirements will change and need to be regularly reevaluated.  

References:

College of Nurses Of Ontario (2000). A Guide on the Use of Restraints. “Communique” January.

Deprospero, R.P., & Bocchino, N. (1999). Restraint Free Care – Is It Possible? American Journal of Nursing 99(10) 27-34.

Fletcher, K. (1996). Use of Restraints in the Elderly. AACN Clinical Issues, 7(4), 611-620.

Gilbert, M., & Counsell, C. (1999). Planned Change to Implement a Restraint Reduction Program. Journal of Nursing Care Quality, 13(5), 57-64.

Knapp, M.B. (1996). Physical Restraint Use in Critical Care: Legal Issues. AACN Clinical Issues, 7(4), 579-584.

Leith, B. (1998). The Use of Restraints in Critical Care. Official Journal of the Canadian Association of Critical Care Nurses, 9(3), 24-28.

Leith, B. (1998). Do Physical Restraints Prevent Patients form Removing Invasive Therapeutic Devices? Official Journal of the Canadian Association of Critical Care Nurses, 9(3), 31-34.

London Health Sciences Centre (2001; February).Revised February  1, 2010.Policy on the Use of Restraints, PCC020.

Maccioli, G., Mazuski, J., Kuszaj, J., Devlin, J. & Peruzzi, W. (2003). Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Maintenance of Patient Physical Safety in the Intensive Care Unit: Use of Restraining Therapies: American College of Critical Care Medicine Task Force 2001-2002, Critical Care Medicine, 31(11), 2665-2676.

Mion, L. (1996). Establishing Alternatives to Physical Restraint in the Acute Care Setting: A Conceptual Framework to Assist Nurses’ Decision Making, AACN Clinical Issues, 7(4), 592-602.

Reigle, J. (1996). The Ethics of Physical Restraints in Critical Care, AACN Clinical Issues, 7(4), 585-591.

Which statement is true regarding the use of patient restraints?

Which statement is true regarding the use of patient restraints? -Restraints are a part of the patients prescribed medical treatment and plan of care. Rationale: If restraints are to be used, they must be a part of a patient's prescribed medical treatment and plan of care.

Which reason would support the use of patient restraints?

Restraints may be used to keep a person in proper position and prevent movement or falling during surgery or while on a stretcher. Restraints can also be used to control or prevent harmful behavior. Sometimes hospital patients who are confused need restraints so that they do not: Scratch their skin.

What are some nursing interventions the nurse should use to facilitate mourning?

Sample interventions include the following:.
Identify the loss..
Assist the patient to identify the initial reaction to the loss..
Listen to expressions of grief..
Encourage discussion of previous loss experiences..
Encourage the verbalization of memories of the loss..
Make empathetic statements about grief..

Which refers to the professional obligation of the nurse to assume responsibility for actions?

Nurses have an obligation to uphold the highest standards of practice, assume full responsibility for actions, and maintain quality in the knowledge base and skill of the profession; this is referred to as accountability.